Hello Friends, How are you? Later today will be part 2 of my 3 day hop. The hop won’t be live until 2pm today Eastern Standard Time and I wanted to make sure you had something in your “inbox” for today.
This my first time for an Instagram hop and I hope you enjoy it 🙂
I am in love with these poinsettias from Mama Elephant. I had some fun outlining my stamped images with a thick border of black sharpie. For the main poinsettia I let the feathering show on the petals.
In this photo I gave the entire poinsettia a wash with a light color and this give the flower a softer look. Which one do you like best?
GIVEAWAY: How about a goodie bag with a Mama Elephant stamp. To qualify tell me if you like number 1 or number 2 better.
I will announce a random winner Wed. Nov.14th.
SEE YOU AT 2 PM TODAY FOR MORE INSPIRATION & A DIFFERENT GIVEAWAY. Hugs, Kathy
P.S. A BIG thanks to Mama Elephant for the giveaway 🙂 Woo Hoo
Susie Moore says
I love them both. But #1 wins if I have to choose.
Swapna Patil says
To be frank i love no 6.. but given options i would go with no.2
Love your colouring…
Marianne says
Love how the contrast in the feathered version makes the flower pop, so no. 1 is my favourite of the two.
Marianne x
Glennis F says
I like the vibrancy of number one
Carmen GR says
I love the soft color of number two
Sandie says
I would have to pick ……. number ONE !!!
Ruth says
Don’t make me choose!!! I like them both, but would save number one from a burning building 🙂 xx
Joyce says
2, because everything is better with a friend.
And beautiful poinsettia!
Ali T. says
I just love #2!! So pretty!!
Lisa T says
Of course I love them both, but number 1 sings to me as it is so vibrant and lush! It’s like choosing your favourite child, you should never have to!!!! Xx
Thordis says
They are both gorgeous, but if I have to choose then the first one, but I love the peachy color on number 2. Thanks for this awesome challenge 🙂
sally says
They are both fabulous but I love the vibrancy of no.1.
Silvia says
I love the both, but my favourite one is Number 1.
Magda says
I love no. 2. It looks much real for me.
Amanda says
Number 2! There are few things I love more than pink and yellow flowers!
Pooja says
I loved tbe first look more 🙂
Aileen Ryan says
Both are stunning Kathy but if I had to choose I like the softness of the second.
stephanie says
Hi Kathy, I like both BUT i am always fascinated by how you mange to go from very dark to very light so I’d pick number 1 😉
Tasha says
Oh, Kathy, they both look gorgeous! But I would go for the first one! I find it more crisp and vivid, and closer to my style 😉 Thanks for sharing these! And for a giveaway!)))
Tess Hackett says
My choice would be the soft number 2. I like the soft and delicate look that it gives to the card.
Lindarub says
I like number one but both are really nice.
Trish Klemann says
I love them both but I think the second, softer one better 🙂
Sandra H says
l like both and cannot choose!! x
Cindy C. says
Both awesome!! But I enjoy the second one more.
Bunny says
Number 1.
Heather - housesbuiltofcards says
They are both stunning! I think I like the detail on the first one best!
Heather says
Love the second one!
sandym says
I love this poinsettia stamp set, too! Love the first one better, colors so vibrant!
Kimberly Rendino says
Super pretty! I like the first one best. The highlight looks amazing!!
Fiki says
love them both!
both are so pretty! but if I have to choce is tnumber 2.
because its softer.
thank you and a Mama Elephant for this giveaway.
hugs
Carolyn E says
Beautiful coloring! Love the boldness of using a sharpie, going to try that one.
I do like both, but I would have to choose the first one, it’s just so vibrant!!!
Pat V says
Great colors! I like number 2. Thank you!
Terri Burson says
Both are winners but number 1 has the edge!
Cruella says
O my. difficult one. No1 is more vibrant but I like the blend of no2 better… both are just as pretty…. I’ll say Number one then!
Cruella says
oooo and I forgot! I LOVE Mama Elephant stamps in general and this poinsettia is absolutely Georg’s!
Janett Ray says
I would pick 1 I love the glow that it has.
Becca Yahrling says
I had to go back & forth so many times to be able to choose because they
are both so lovely. I think I like No. 2 better with the light wash.
cathym53 says
I like the number two better. One is lonely.
cathym53 says
Oh, you were talking about the cards .. still number 2. Love the coloring.
Arianna Barbara says
I love them both but n.1 wins because the vibrant colors are absolutely stunning!!!
Thank you and Mama Elephant for this great chance to win!!!
Pocono Pam says
I Loooooove them both But #1 is my fave!
JodyT says
Ugh! I can’t choose. I like them both for different reasons. I like the play of light on number 1 but I like the softness of number 2.
Dee Earnshaw says
I like the vibrancy of the colors in #1 BUT both are gorgeous:)
Mel H says
Very close, but I think I’ll go with number two.
Alba says
Love the first one Kathy!
Yukiko Sugiyama says
Both really amazing! Beautiful coloring! But if I have to choose I like #1! Really pretty!
Marcia says
Both are beautiful – but I like how #1 looks 3D.
Marcia Scantlin says
One of course
Cathy says
Both are so pretty, but I love the softer look of number 2!
MO says
#2! Cool way to use this pretty stamp.
Gabriella says
I like number one better, thanks for asking
Tami B says
They’re both really pretty, but I like number one a little bit more.
Amy Yang says
Both are so beautiful. I guess I’ll choose one cause the colors are more interesting.
Diane Morales says
Love them both,but number 1 has that pop if color.
Annie S. says
I love the vibrancy and the textured look of #1
Kristina CraftyPaws says
Love them both, but as a more CAS girl, I have to say that the crisper colors of #1 appeal to me a teeny bit more. 🙂
Sara Andrews says
Hmmm…that’s tough as both are beautiful. I’m going to go with #1 because it puts the spotlight on that one flower.
Janet Swain says
I love #1. The softer one may look better in person, but the vibrant colors of #1 look fantastic.
Eileen says
I love both, but I prefer #1…I am into bright vibrant colors!
Carol Casavant says
Love, love, love #1…!!
Lynn R says
The Black Sharpie marker is genius!! How beautiful that turned out. I must try that technique my first opportunity. I’m definitely a fan of #1
Pam T, says
Both are so pretty but #2 just jumped out at me!!!! You are so talented.
Rose says
1 hands down! Love the vivid color of it but both are truly gorgeous.
Pam Hammarlund says
Don’t make me choose. Well, okay, if I have to, I would say # 1. They are both gorgeous.
Dina Carroll says
In general I prefer the brush strokes on most flowers. In this card I like the blended a bit more. Both are great.
Kathy Serrahn says
Both are great but I love #1 better
Diane Jaquay says
#2 (it always makes me think of me and my awesome hubby!)
Jane Crisci says
I love them both, but if I have to pick, I would pick number 2. Thanks Kathy and thank you Mama Elephant!
Marissa M. says
Both are nice, but I like the texture of #1 better 🙂
Majda says
This is really hard. I love them both. OK… then maybe Nr. 2. 🙂
Lynda Kong says
I love both but if I have to pick only one then it has to be #1 because the vibrancy of the colours are greatly enhanced by the use of bold black outlines. The feminine floral colours and forms actually remind me of the oriental prints on the clothes that my mum used to put on when I was a little girl. I do miss her so.
Jo D says
They are both lovely. But since I have to choose I’ll say #1, it pops more.
Thanks for the give away.
Donna Rinckel says
Both cards a beautiful, Kathy. I love the thick marker lines around the poinsettias too. That’s a great idea. I like number 1 better. The bold colors just speak to me. Have a great day!
Barbara Schubert says
I prefer the softer look of #2.
Caoimhe says
Love #2!
Sharna W. says
I’ll have to go with 1 because I like the contrast.
Wendy Goundrey says
Hi Kathy. I like number 1 better. That poinsettia looks so real!
Tara Prince says
I like number 1 best but they are both beautiful!!
Leanne in Cali says
They are both beautiful, but I like #1 better with more white “highlights” in it. Thanks for sharing!
Amy Cooley says
#2 is my favorite! I like the highlights!
Dorothy says
Both are beautiful, but I like #1 the best. The colors are more vibrant and really catch the eye!
Dot Freel says
I love them both but I prefer the blended #2 more. Love how you mix colors.
Lori-Ann S Ball says
Number One, only because I like the feathering that you did. I like the color you used in Number two, but the feathering is not the same, but honestly…they are both stunning!
Trina P. says
Both are beautiful and if I had to choose, it’s the second softer look.
Cynthia Cole says
I like number one!
Beverly Parkison says
Of course they are both really pretty, but since we have to choose I will go with #2
Sharon Shulsky says
I love the coloring of the 1st one. It gives such great dimension to the flower.
Nicole says
A difficult decision!! I thought I would go #2 because it has more yellow tones (I think everything needs a bit of yellow), but I actually like #1 better. 🙂
Kimberly Pelkey says
Both are fabulous but I think I like #1 best!
Olga Dendrinou Fink says
Both are gorgeous! but I really do love #1
xoxo Olga
Karen Lai says
I love both really but if I hav to choose #1 lol. Beautiful coloring!
Lisa Zurek says
I like #2 the best.
Kerry says
I really like them both. I would pick number 1 because of the vibrant colors makes it pop just slightly more. I really like seeing the feather strokes. Beautiful job.
Carol D says
I love the feathering in #1. Somehow it looks more “arty” to me (whatever that means!). Love to watch you color, Kathy!
Amy Seech says
I like the first one best! The bold out lines make it look like stained glass.
Pat Baker says
I like the POP of color in No. 1 – so that’s my vote!!!
Judy McGoodwin says
as usual, both beautiful….however, 😉 I like #2 the best. A little softer.
Kathleen Mc says
Personally, I prefer the top one. I like that there is a contrast there.
Kathleen Mc xx
Cindi Hall says
I like # 1 better. The colors look brighter and more defined. Both are gorgeous though.
Erika Lee says
It’s so hard, but I think like the distinct feathering on #1 the best. So pretty!
Debbie V says
Both are lovely, but I prefer the feathering of number 1.
Jean Marmo says
Wow – equally gorgeous! Love the softer colors of 2.
Linda Fletcher says
Love the poinsettias!! I like them both, but # 1 gets my vote. So cheery!!
Peggy Pride says
I like #1. I always like bright colors. Using the Sharpie outlining is new to me.
Melanie says
Love them both but would pick no.1 if I have to choose.
Linda Tupper says
Beautifully colored flowers. I choose #2
Laura Jane says
Hi Kathy! I like the obvious feathering on the first one. My hope is to learn how to get that EVENLY feathered look as you always seem to do:))
Lucie Renee says
Being a traditionalist, I prefer the first one. I am enjoying watching you color.
Amy says
I lik them both but I vote for #2.
Marcia Harrington says
Wow!! That’s a hard one. . . but I find I’m drawn to #1 a little more!!
Nataliea says
I also think both are beautiful, but I favor number one.
Maryam says
Love them both. I will choose Flower Number 1 by it self is so vibrant and I love the colours.but if it’s with the whole design and the side roses in the card I will choose number 2 it goes more with the other coloured in the card.
Sue McRae says
I like the #1 because it’s more vibrant.
Beverly Jordan says
I love both but #2 is my pick. Happy coloring!!
Rhandi D says
#1 is definitely my favorite. I love it because of the vibrant colors. Thanks for the chance to win.
Nancy S says
#1 is my favorite, I like vibrant colors and the texture from ‘flicking’…is that the right word, lol.
Janice Upton says
You did a fantastic job of coloring on both but I prefer the first one. It seems to be more realistic looking.
Rebecca says
I love the way number 1 pops off the page, so that would be my choice. They’re both gorgeous though!
Diane says
I love the bright contrast of #1. I also think I would prefer a thinner black sharpie line. Love your coloring!
Moira OReilly says
I love them both; it’s so hard to pick a winner. The first is more vibrant and bold, whereas the second is softer and perhaps more elegant. For a Christmas card, I would go for the first (how is that for waffling LOL ????)
Valerie Breingan says
I like the show of the bold highlight in #1.
Anne Lewis says
I love them both but will go with number 2 . The colors are soooo beautiful and guess what? My birthday is Nov. 14th. and I’m still going strong at 82. Love your 30 day challenge and all the beautiful cards it has. It gives me ideas for many of my cards.
Kathy Racoosin says
Early Happy Birthday. You are an impressive young lady. I’m thrilled to know I can inspire you with new ideas. Thanks for being a part of the 30 Day CC. 🙂
Marie Siler says
I like both, but the highlite in No. 1 is very striking. So No. 1 for me.
Jean says
I like #1 the best. more contrast and I like the feathering.
Jennifer K says
They are both gorgeous but I like #1 best, I think it is more vibrant and the petals have lots of dimension.
sharla~ says
They are both gorgeous, you are like the queen of flowers!! I like #2, it keeps the colors, but does blend it and soften it which turns out really pretty!! 🙂
Donna Lee Williams says
THey are both lovely. If I have to choose one, it would be #1.
Laurie Newbigging says
I love both, but I like the warmth of #2
Joyce Erb says
#1, love the color
Woendi Levitt says
There both beautiful depending on the look your going for and a close up look always changes in the viewers eye but….I’d have to say #1. I like the bold color and how the black defines each color. TY for the chance to have a goodie bag and to Mama Elephant. Good luck to everyone!!
Marcie Lovett says
They’re both beautiful, but I think I have to go with 1
Carolee McCaslin says
They are both beautiful but if I had to choose I would say #1:)
Dot says
I like #1 better. So pretty! They both are, but I really like #1.
Vinita Jain says
Both are gorgeous poinsettias, but no# i steal my heart with such vibrant colors!
Conny Hillgaard says
I like the vibrancy of number one – though # 2 is pretty too.
Billi-Jo Perry says
Both are beautiful but I think I like #1 a tiny bit more
Lynn Reloza says
Both are awesome but since you’re making me choose, i really like #2 more.
Traci Brennan says
Number 1…love the vibrancy.
Teresa Cherka says
My favorite is #1, the highlighting on the petals is really pretty. Thanks for sharing.
Lisascreativeniche says
Oh I love the yellow on card #2!!!
Kathy Thisted says
they are both fantastic but if I have to pick one – i like the vibrancy of #1 best.
DonnaC says
Kathy, it’s a difficult choice since both colorings are awesome, but I would choose #1.
Di W says
Both are amazing, but, I like the brighter color in #1 best. Lovely.
Beverly Atkins says
Very difficult choice! The first one pops and the second one is soft and calming. I would use both but when pushed to pick one I’m thinking I’d choose the one that pops and that would be #1.
Becky Partan says
I love #2 the best, although they are both beautiful. I just like the softness of #2.
Hoosier says
I like number one – bright for me!
Andrea C says
I love them both, but #1 wins for the brilliant contrast!
Sheri K says
They are both pretty, but I like the 1 better. Have a fun hop today–it’s smack dab in the middle of work this afternoon–no desk job or “breaks” for me–I’m one on one with clients the entire time. Hope you all have fun! I’m still trying to get to yesterday’s hop–just run out of time before leaving for work.
LAla Larson says
Love the brightness of number one. Beautiful.
Rachel says
I like #1!
Dolores Ingraham says
I love them both but if I had to choose I think it would be #1.
carol says
Both are incredibly pretty, but I’ll give #1 the slightest edge *grin* Instagram hop? This will be a first for me, too (as was adding a card into the Day 3 FB group)! Learning new stuff is fun as is seeing all the incredible inspiration!
~carol
Constance Hildebrand says
I pick #2. Lovely.
Nancy Wilcox says
I like the brightness and vibrant color of #1 the best.
Lisa Gross says
I love #1 but #2 is pretty also.
Rachel Behzadi says
Tough choice..I like them both. However I’m drawn to #1 because of how vibrant the colors are.
Lavonne says
I like #2. But both are very nice. Love your coloring. 🙂
Heidi says
I like number 1 better: darker in the shadow areas and lighter highlight, causes more contrast in the whole flower.
Debby Turner says
Oh my gosh I love #1. I love the bright colors!
Salina Z says
I love them both, but today I am in a soft mood. So #2 gets my vote. Thanks for sharing.
Lu C says
I love poinsettias period. Brightness wins in this case!
Hilda Escobedo says
I love number 1
Cheryl Horvath says
Number 1 – it’s gorgeous and looks like rays of sunshine shining down on it.
Kaylin Krawczyk says
i like number 2.
Tona says
They’re both fantastic, but forced to choose I will say #2.
Linda Knox says
Both are beautiful on their own but viewing side by side I prefer #1. Thanks for the giveaway.
Alexandra S says
They are both gorgeous ! but my fav is nr 1 I think because of the white which makes the colors more vibrant and also liking the feathering details <3
RebeccaL says
I love the bold colors of #1. Lovely card!
Pearl says
I like the second one better with the peach in the petals 🙂
Kristen Lee says
This was a tough one but since I must choose, I pick #1 because I love how the white that is left in the poinsettia really brings out the lovely reds.
Lanae F says
I like how bright and bold the first one is!
BunnyD says
Love version # 1 I love the streaks ofcolour blending are so pretty. Looks fabulous on the flower petals.
Theresa P says
I like #1 the best but both are beautiful.
Michael says
I love No. 1 more because of the bold outline. The poinsettia also pops more in the No. 1 than in No. 2. Not that I don’t love No. 2 also …. LOL
Julie H in MN says
Number 1 is my pick!
Terri (terriavidreader) Scott says
I like #1 better, seems much brighter.
Patt H. says
Both flowers are gorgeous but the pure vibrant look of #1 really caught my eye. Love your awesome coloring!!
Rebecca Ednie says
I like #2 because it better matches the rest of the coloring.
Jane says
Love them both but no. 1 is my favourite
Joanb says
NUmber 1 is my favorite, but I like 2 also.
Barb Schmidtt says
Tough choice, but being a “tropical Florida gal” , I go with number 2, It’s sunnier and warmer feeling… Love them both
Mervi says
Both so pretty, no 2 is mine;-))m
Jennifer T says
I like the #2 better…I don’t like to choose first, it’s always been a hard thing for me. Going 2nd is easier
Loly Borda says
Perfection as usual! I chose number 2 but both are fabulous!
Marie K. says
Hard to say but I guess #1.
Beth Karschnick says
Hey Kathy, I always love all your coloring but as I see these right next to each other I guess I like the first one the best. It was hard to choose though….
Thank you Kathy and Mama Elephant for today’s give away!!!
Stinne says
Both of them looks pretty… but i like number one best. I like the feather stroke…
So fun to be part of this colouring challenge.
Alicia M says
I like #1 better because the shading and highlighting make it look almost 3 dimensional
Cheryl Robertson says
Hard to choice one over the other but if I have to I’ll say number 2. It’s a softer/calmer version.
Andrea1702 says
They’re both lovely, but I prefer the soft look of number 2.
Rosy Newlun says
Good morning Kathy ♥ It’s only 7:50 a.m. here, so going on 8 a.m. eastern time. I’ve never done an IG hop. What is that? I’ll try to figure it out lol!!! I love the poinsettia you did with the touches of yellow? on the petals. Not sure if that is one or two. Thank you Mama Elephant and all the sponsors this month >’x'< aloha!!!
Kathy Racoosin says
If you have an IG account just start from my blog post for today. There is a list of hoppers. Just click on a name and go look. Come back to my blog post to click on the next name. That’s probably the easiest. If you don’t have an IG account it’s easy to get one for free. Hope this all helps.:)
Susie Sonnier says
#1. It just seems “brighter” with the lighter highlight
Carla Hundley says
Gorgeous coloring
on both and I do like
the second one better
Carla from Utah
AnnB says
So hard to choose! Both are beautiful but number one so vibrant so I’d pick that one 🙂
Mary W says
Number 1 is my choice but they are both really pretty – just love the background.
Shelli says
Really?! I have to pick a favorite? I read it twice because I was sure you did not really mean to pick one? I love the fisrt one, the coloring is so great. I also love the second one because it is softer and meshes with the softer colors around it. I guess I clearly can not pick….I love them both but will choose 2, even though I love bright colors that pop…mmmm… So hard to make a choice!
Jeanne-Marie says
I like number 1 the best! They are both beautiful, but I really love your feathering-it’s so perfect! I feel the feathering really makes the flower pop!
nancy Vondra says
#1 Rocks for me!
Sharon Brand says
#1 is my choice – it seems more vibrant!
The colouring in both is fantastic!
Leanne S says
I like both. If I have to choose one, I guess the first being more vibrant.
Alyce says
I prefer #1. I like the contrast of the highlights.
Karen Page says
#1 is gorgeous but it somehow just doesn’t look right with the surrounding images… maybe because its the only thing colored that way? I find #2 more pleasing to the eye *overall* based on the background. But all bets are off if you had colored the flowers and leaves similarly in #1, cause that sure was pretty!
Rosslyn W. says
#2 is so pretty. Love the soft look.
SusanME says
I love the softness of #2, but the way that #1 pops against the others. Hmmmmm…. I guess if I had to take sides, #2. 😀
Sabrina Radican says
They are both very beautiful but I am kind of leaning more towards number 1.
Tracey Magner says
Number 1 gets my vote ,Both are BEAUTEFUL !!!!
Cyndia says
I like number two the best! I just think it looks more like the real thing!
Karen.O says
Of course they are both very beautiful but I like number 1 just an incy bit more.
Shayrn Seaboryne says
I like number one! Nice and bright. Excited about my first time on the 30 day challenge!
Tasha Dawson says
I love the bright colors in photo #1. Gives it such a nice POP of color.
Susan G says
I think I like the first one best, probably because the colors are more striking. But, I really like the second one because it looks more realistic. They’re both beautiful. Your coloring hits it out of the park again. Beautiful!!!
Michelle C says
#1 is my favourite though they both look gorgeous and realistic!
Angela Pahl says
♥ Both versions are really wonderful, but the first i prefer a little bit more. So my favorite is Number 1.
Many hugs
Angela
Kelly Szafron says
Both are so pretty but I pick #1.
Lee says
#1. The highlights really make it glow and it’s so bright and gorgeous. More contrast too. Definitely my fave.
Diva Kreszl says
They are both lovely but my favorite is number one, I love the vibrancy!
Debbi S says
They’re both beautiful, but I like the feathering in #1 more than the soft look.
rae jones says
They are both stunning but I think I would have to choose number 2. It has a kind of warm glow.
Kathy H says
This decision depends very much on mood and time of day. #1 is more vibrant and positive, very morning get up and go feel. On the other hand #2 is more mellow and laid back, a sort of dreamy end of the day feel. This means I get to like them both equally! Thanks for sharing your lovely work and super tips.
Melitta Ball says
You know Kathy, I can’t pick a favorite because I like them both for different reasons…#1 is very bright and appears more dimensional and is very ‘center stage’. #2 is much softer and no one element is competing with another to be ‘center stage’ so it gives a very ‘overall’ cohesive look. Sorry just can’t pick! Thanks for the inspiration!
Blessings,
Melitta
Linda Carson says
Big time vote for #1
barb macaskill says
Both are beautiful but I like the vibrancy of the colors on number 1! Thanks for showing different techniques on each one!
Berina Febin says
I love the first one!! It’s beautiful!! Your coloring is always an eye candy!!
-Berina
Moxie Craftie
bev p says
My opinion (for what it’s worth!): I like the second one. It helps tie in the color of the primary image into the others. I think there is enough boldness in other elements that the colors of the flowers don’t need so much contrast. Thanks, Kathy. PS Now I know why you commented on my “too many bloghops” comment! (big grin!!!) I finished yesterday’s while I ate lunch today. I will be doing good to start this evening on today’s after the grandkids’ soccer game! Off to watch kids run.
Shelley C says
Both are gorgeous, but like the bolder color in #1.
Chris Baker Cox says
Love them both, but I would choose #2. I like that they don’t look as “shiny”.
Ruth says
Both are beautiful but I liked number 1 better, the white space makes it look more vibrant.
irene grau says
They’re both lovely, but I like the brightness of #1. Thanks for the challenge and giveaway!!
Jennifer Lubinsky says
I love number 1. They are both so pretty, but I prefer 1.
Debra C. says
I think both of them is gorgeous but if I had to choose it would be 2. I wish I had your talent.
Jan O says
Number 1 for me!
Betty Sue says
I love the first one as I’m a more traditional poinsettia type of girl!!
Karleigh says
Hi Kathy, I’m a newbie to colouring in really enjoying being part of the colour challenge thank you. I really love the first flower number one it has alot of depth it jumps out at you, and it almost has a real shine to it, its the one that pulled me in first x
Kathy Racoosin says
Welcome to the 30 Day CC. I’m thrilled you found me and most of you are enjoying coloring. The key of the challenge is to find special time just for you. Thabk you 🙂
Kathy Racoosin says
Welcome! Great to hear how much uou are enjoying the coloring challenge. Continue to find that special time just for you.Thank you for your kind words and support. 🙂
Kathy S says
Love both images especially with the extra dark outline. I love the vibrancy of the colours in number 1 but the smoothness of the blending of colours in number 2. I think number 1 would win my vote if I had to choose.
Diane says
I love them both but would go with the first if I have to choose. It somehow seems more vibrant to me.
Diane F says
I love them both but choose the first if I have to pick only one. It somehow seems more vibrant to me.
Janet Cobb says
Both are beautiful…but I think I like the softer look of #2 best.
Angelique Vela says
I would go with 2. I’m a soft and subtle woman so the more blended look appeals more to me.
Pam says
Vibrancy of no. 1 wins for me!!
Rene Stansell says
They are both lovely in their own way but I go for No 2 as it is softer.
Rene from OZ xo
Pamela Ratcliff says
I think I like the shade of red in #1 a bit better
Diane Loughrey says
Number 1
Kathy Salido says
Both are beautiful, but my favorite is #1
Diane Bakehouse says
If I created any one of them I would be extremely happy, but I prefer the vibrancy of #1.
Pai Meng says
number 1!
rae jones says
Lovely colours. Both fab but 2 gets my vote
rae jones says
Lovely colours. Both fab but 2 gets my vote
Judy Sander says
My preferance is number 1, but love them both.
Judy B says
They are both lovely Kathy, but I prefer card 2. Thanks for sharing.
Gretchen Wilson says
Oh Wow! I believe after much thought and looking, I like number one the most!
susan a Lorio says
i love them both but f i had to pick it would be #2. thanks for all you do.
heidi Lilley says
I truly have to say I love #1 the best, it is much more bright and vibrant. thank you for the chance to win.
Lynne in NI says
They’re both fab, but I’d probably go for #1 – I think it’s the brighter highlights I like.
Gwendolyn says
Both are gorgeous but i prefer the shine on the 1st one. Now I wished i’d seen this post before colouring my poinsettias!
Susan Wareham says
I like #1 better but both are great! Instagram hop was fun would say easier I could visit them all
nancy says
I like number two best because it looks so good with the background colors.
jengd says
While this is lovely, I have to say I like the other one more. I like the sharpness of the flowers and pop of them against the white background.
Miriam Leech says
Both are beautiful, but #1 gets my vote!! Thanks!!
Cindy Roman Daversa says
I can’t choose..don’t make me choose…I love both!
Pat Crank says
Hard to pick my favorite as I love both…the subtle look to the second one has a very slight edge over the first one!
Laurie says
I pick Number One!! They are both stunning but i love the feathering on the petals!!
Denise Candelaria says
They are both beautiful but I like 2 the blend is nice on 2.
Bobbie says
As far as I am concerned all of your work Kathy is my favorite but if I had to choose which in this case I really really want to be a winner I have to go with one. It’s brighter and to me like you cheerful.
Kathy Racoosin says
AWW thanks, 🙂
Jessica Hess says
Beautiful! I like #2 better, but only because you are making me pick. 😉
Lisa says
It’s tough. But I’m going with number 1! I like them both though
Becky M says
Both are gorgeous, but I’d choose #1 as my favorite!
Michelle N says
I think I like #1 the best but they’re both sooo lovely!
Angela Rogalski says
Hi , I really didn’t have to think hard or very long for this one . I love #1 hands down ! I love the feathering it really adds a special touch !
Angela
Laurie DiGregorio says
I love #1! The vibrant colors are stunning and just pop off the page, showing off the beautiful details!
Nancee Purdum says
Oh I definitely like #1 better! So bright! Love this! 🙂
Cecil Livesay says
I like 1 best. It reminds me of the poinsettias growing wild in our yard while living in Kona, Hawaii. The petals were highlighted by the Hawaiian sun, especially in the morning hours. Lovely!
Regina says
I like both, #1 for it’s volume and #2 for it’s softer colors… Overall #2 looks more realistic, so I’ll choose #2!
And thank you for sharing both versions, Kathy, your coloring is beautiful!
Connie Myers says
#1 is my favorite – just on personal preference. Thanks for the idea of using a sharpie on the outline, Kathy!
Kathy H says
#1 is my favorite because of the brighter highlights!
Carolyn says
I like how distinct the highlights are on #1. But they are both stunning. Truly.
TammyJ says
#1 I would have to say but you make it really hard because I love them both.
Natalie Godfrey says
Both of them looks good but #1 for me because it looks a lot more bolder than the 2nd one.
Carol K says
both are lovely, my prefernce would be #1. . . really like the strokes. . . .
KT Fit Kitty says
These are both absolutely stunning but I chose #1 because it looks more vibrant. Your colouring always amazes me!
Elise S. says
Both poinsettias are beautiful but I like #1 a little better for Christmas. It’s so vibrant 🙂
Laura Buehler says
I love them both, but I love #2 a tiny bit more because of the color combo. Thanks.
Linda Grady says
Poinsettia’s are my favorite holiday image. I think I would have to say that #1 catches my eye more and pops. Both are beautiful!
FeM says
I love poinsettias!!! Your coloring is so lifelike and choosing one is difficult. But if, and only if, I have to pick one, I’ll go with #1. Thanks for the inspiration.
DenaAnn Schaufele says
Not fair making us chose. Both are great.
Trina Chaska says
They are both pretty, but I would have to pick number 2.
Janet Ingraham says
I would not throw either away, both beautiful but I do like the more subdued look of #2 better.
Cindy Wilson says
I like the vibrancy of no 1.
Mindy says
Both are absolutely stunning but I’d have to go with number one. Love the more vibrant colors!
Barbara Walborn says
I like the softer look of number 2.
Lucy Schmidt says
Today I prefer #2 because I’ve been running around all day and need to chill out a bit. Tomorrow, I’ll be rested and probably need a pick-me-up to get my energy back on par so I’d go with #1 then. Time, place, circumstance all make a difference in my card choice. I wouldn’t put either in recycling, though. They’re both keepers.
Janet Sisk says
I love #1. The white accents just pop more to me. Thanks for the inspiration and chance to win a cool goodie bag. 😀
Rufus says
Gah! That’s a toughie…I like the boldness of #1, but the softer maybe more realistic look of #2. It’s like your kids, no favorites allowed!
Stephanie W says
I love the color pop of #1. Both are beautiful but if I have to pick, #1 gets my vote.
Laurie Brown says
Both gorgeous but I like #1 the best!!
Amy Colligan says
Love them both❤️️ Number 2 is my fave!
Samantha Johnson says
I like #1 best, but both are lovely
Mimi R says
I like number 2!
Denise Bryant says
I like #1! Those rich colors remind me of velvet! Makes the poinsettias look so beautiful!
Jeannie Brown says
I like number 1.
Traci Starkweather says
Hi Kathy!
I usually prefer bold and crisp colors on projects. On this Christmas themed piece I like the 2nd option more. It is softer looking and reminds me of all of the overwhelming love I see in the world especially at Christmas.
Thanks for the chance to win! And thank you Mama Elephant, too!
He-IS-Able!
Traci Starkweather tracistarkweather@gmail.com
Gail Plaskiewicz says
I love them both and there is nothing wrong with either. The first one though pops out more then the second one. It’s more noticeable if you know what I mean. Would I not like to receive the second one in my mailbox? Of course not. You asked and I told you. I didn’t get to color today. We didn’t go to see my dad for very long so I brought my library book and I finished it. 1 down and about 10 more to go! LOL I love to color and I love to read. When we go visit my dad, he’s not much of a talker and he doesn’t hear to well (he refuses to wear his hearing aids) so I bring something to do. If I don’t, I am watching TV and sometimes I fall asleep. I am making some amazing Christmas cards and I will post them on your site. I really like you’re coloring and I love Mama Elephant. Thanks for letting us win something!
Jayne says
Your cards are always beautiful Kathy. I like both but No 1 is sharper :)) and like that. Happy day
Anna.K says
Um… both are awesome! And my win is 1st one! 🙂 Just love the color pick!
p.s. Thank you! & Mama Elephant!!! Woo-hoo!
SandraA says
I had to look back and forth at the photos to try and pick one, but it was hard to do as I really like them both. But if I must select one, I guess it would be the feathered poinsettia in Photo 1. TFS.
Oliev says
Hey Kathy, number one is my favorite:-)
Kathleen Reilly says
They both are beautiful but if I had to pick just one I think it would be Number One (1)
Kathleen
Melissa E says
Number one….the contrast is really gorgeous
Bette says
i like no.1 as i like bright or bold colors and the touch of white makes it bright. no.2 reminds me of vintage….. smiles for all your coloring and mama elephant rocks!
Solfrid H says
Your colouring amazes me! Both are beautiful, but I’d go with number 1.
Patti G says
I like the softer #2
Adrianne says
I love how vibrant the first poinsettia looks but they both are beautiful. 🙂
Anja Bytyqi says
Both look absolutely stunning! Love the colors you’ve chosen. I think I like the first a tiny bit better because of the detail.
Elea says
I like both but I would choose # 2
Debbie says
Love #1
Sue Geyer says
Number 1 really catches my attention. The poinsettia just jumps off the page. I do love poinsettias
renuka singhal says
I love #1..I love those colors
Teresa Doyle says
Jeez, decisions, decisions…LOL
Awww…..They are BOTH beautiful. # 1 looks brighter so I’ll go with that!
Melody Blake says
Both are beautiful! Thanks for the Instagram hop! I am loving it, and it is faster than a blog hop when one is short on time and still wants to color!
Terry B. says
I like #1.
valerie wood says
Love both, but right now I love #1 just a bit more!
Lynn says
I prefer # 1. Color is a lot brighter!
Nancy Bachman says
Both are gorgeous but it is #1 for me. Loving this stamp and your coloring is spectacular!!
Ann Reisinger says
I really love them both, but like no. 2 a little better because of the way the subtle last layer blends the color.
Ronda says
I love them both but I am drawn to the softer tones in the second one.
Essie says
Number one is my favorite, although they are both gorgeous. I love how bold your coloring is. I feel as though I can spot a Kathy piece immediately. Distinctively, vibrantly you!
Karen P. says
Beautiful Poinsettias. Love the coloring. From the Pro!
Sandra Bannert says
I prefer the 2nd with the softer blending – but both are beautiful!
Zehra says
Beautiful, like the bright one
Number 2
Cynthia Johnson says
I think #1 because it has some shine in it.
Abby says
I like #1. Nice and bright!
Karen says
Since I only have two choices I Love number 2, however they all are great
Jean Bullock says
Both flowers look great. I prefer the one with the feathering.
Kris in Alaska says
I live them both but the brighter of the two really catches my eye!
Georgia says
Both are beautiful . #2 if I must choose .
Erin C. says
Please don’t make me choose! LOL Honestly, Kathy, I love everything you do (seriously)!!! BUT, since you want me to pick one, I’m going to have to say the first one (with the flicks showing). They’re both just gorgeous though!! (And thanks to Mama Elephant for the generous prize!)
Mary-Anne V. says
Both are very pretty but I like the first one with the distinct flicking is my favourite.
Patty Eifert says
They all look awesome…but I do really love the feathering!!
Mary Holshouser says
I’m more comfortable being #2.
thanks.
Miriam Prantner says
So pretty! I think I like #1 best, I love the contrast!
Marina says
It is difficult to choose, I really like them both. Euhm, maybe I like number 1 a bit more.
Nupur Priya says
I love the 1st one as I like bright & vibrant colors!
meghan says
I love the soft color of number two
deborah kaye says
I like #1 the best.
Maureen Hayes says
The number 1
Janet says
I # 1
vivien lee says
Option 2!
cassi says
I love these poinsettias with the thick border! The second is my favorite, and I am loving this challenge. Thanks for all the fun.
Milka says
Hi Kathy. Both are beautiful, but I like 1st one more. I love bright colors! :o) Thank you so much for the opportunity to win ME goodies and for the inspiration. :o) Big hugs!! :o)
D.Ann C says
Oh, it’s so hard to decide! I like the little pop of white on the petals in # 1, but I also like the more natural, the smoothed out colors in #2…. I still think I prefer #1 jus a smidge more. : )
Sue LD says
I like the one with the soft wash of color.
Raluca Vezeteu says
I prefer number 1 😀 Hugs xx
Nandini Karmarkar says
Wow! Beautiful colouring on both. Love the first just a little more though.
Bev Chapman says
Wow that is gorgeous!
_chevron2 says
The first one is the colors that I most associate with you–or you use a lot;) however they are both beautiful!
Carey Nusbaum says
Kathy, you are the coloring queen! Your coloring is stunning! I love both poinsettias, but would have to choose #1! Thanks for the inspiration and for the opportunity to win! Happy coloring!
Marlyn Rojas says
Both are gorgeous, but I prefer number2.
Diane says
I love them both, but #1 is my favorite. I so enjoy watching you create such magic. Thanks for all the great inspiration.
Nancy Deffner says
#2 is my favorite
eva says
How beautiful are both poinsettias! But I prefer the bold colors from the first one.
Annette Hindes says
Both pretty but like #2 a little better
more depth
Joyce Erb says
I like the vibrancy of #1
Alina Bartan says
Gorgeous coloring! I love the first one due to the higher contrast!
Paulette Still says
Hi Kathy! I like 1 better but both are gorgeous. Thanks. Hope I get to play!
Angie Hall says
I like no. 1 best. I’m for bright and bold for poinsettias.
Kari V. says
I like #1! Beautiful!
Katrina H says
#1
Karen M says
Love them both, but the softer look of #2 is my favorite. This stamp is gorgeous.
Sandra says
If you’re really going to make me choose….lol….I also like #1!
Nadja says
I love both of them….. But if I’d have to choose, I would say number 1 ❤️
Judie Attard says
Stunning colouring! I think I prefer number 1 as the colour of the flower is brighter!
Lagene says
#1 is my favorite. Both are gorgeous though!
Maggie Arambarry says
They are both very pretty, but I prefer #1 .
🙂
Barbara Burgess says
I love your work…My favorite is #1. I think it has a brighter look.
TracyM #6773 says
They’re both GORGEOUS!!!
Today I prefer #2, the softer colour is like a warm hug for my eyes 🙂
Flo says
Both are great but I prefer the clean white background in number2. Thanks.
Pat says
These are both beautiful but for me I think No. 2 with the softer look is the one I prefer. x
Linda says
I like both but I choose No. 1.